Monday, March 31, 2014

Consumption Contagion and Income Inequality

The trends of rising income inequality and the declining national savings rate since the early 1980s may be related, according to a paper by Marianne Bertrand and Adair Morse. The authors find that higher levels of visible consumption by increasingly better-off households at the top of the income distribution induces consumers in the lower parts of the income distribution to spend a higher share of their disposable income. From "Consumption Contagion: Does the Consumption of the Rich Drive the Consumption of the Less Rich?":
"Our empirical strategy exploits variation across geographic markets and over time to identify the effect of expenditures by the rich on that of the non-rich. We ask whether, everything else held constant, higher levels of consumption by the rich living in a household’s relevant market (which we define to be either a state or an MSA in a given year) predicts a higher propensity to consume out of disposable income for the non-rich household. After establishing that such vertical consumption correlations occur, we then explore possible mechanisms. Our results are most consistent with the view that visible increased consumption by the rich induces status-seeking or status-maintaining consumption by the less rich."
Bertrand and Morse define the rich households in each state as those with above the 80th percentile of income in that state. Their baseline regression shows that a 1 percent increase in consumption (excluding housing) among the rich in a particular state translates into a 0.07 percent increase in consumption among the less-rich. They find no evidence that this could be explained by the permanent income hypothesis; rising consumption by the rich in a particular state is not predictive of faster future income growth by the state's less-rich. Thus, they conclude that "Our preferred explanation for the vertical consumption spillovers we observed in our basic results is that low and middle income households witness the higher consumption levels by the rich and are tempted to also consume more."

To test this explanation further, they use data from the Consumer Expenditure Survey and use the Ori Heffetz (2011) index to rank goods into seven categories of increasing visibility. Highly visible consumption items include cars, clothing (except underwear!), shoes, and cigarettes; minimally visible consumption items include health or legal accounting services and, yes, underwear. They replicate the analysis by goods category, and find strongest effects in the most visible consumption categories, consistent with a "consumption contagion" explanation.

As another test, they replicate the analysis using Census Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs) instead of states. They use a measure of community segregation, indicating how closely the rich live to the less-rich in each MSA. In MSAs where the rich and less-rich live closer together, there is more consumption contagion.

Overall, the authors estimate that the savings rate of median-income households would be one to two percentage points higher in the absence of this "consumption contagion" effect. This is non-trivial but also not huge. What is most important is the empirical support of a particular type of departure from the Permanent Income Hypothesis. Many types of departures have been hypothesized, but quantifying their relative importance and carefully tracing out their implications for macro models is an ongoing task.

79 comments:

  1. This is one of those things that ordinary people experience every day that economists verify is true. I myself know I am a victim of this -- I can't really afford a tablet but that's what people richer than me seem to be buying, so I put a tablet on my credit card. Or I feel compelled to do that anyway.

    Seeing them on TV and in friends' and family's homes is like a trigger.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I suggest you look at contradictory evidence in the paper by Yuri Gorodnichenko, 'Does Greater Inequality Lead to More Household Borrowing? New Evidence from Household Data', just presented in a London Business School seminar. Should be available at Berkeley!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think our inequality problem would begin to be solved if we raised the minimum wage by one dollar every year.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Richard, yes, I looked at that paper yesterday after someone mentioned it to me on twitter. John Mondragon, one of the coauthors, told me "We expected debt was financing consumption but found no. leaves room for labor supply, liquid wealth, informal debt." So the two papers aren't necessarily contradictory, as one focuses on consumption and the other on debt, but it is an interesting contrast.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Veblen would not have been surprised...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Or see the paper in the first issue of the Review of Behavioral Economics (ROBE) by Robert Frank, Adam Seth Levine, and Oege Dijk entitled "Expenditure Cascades." It already has a Wikipedia entry and basically makes the same argument.

    Barkley Roser

    ReplyDelete
  7. norton.com/setup - Norton security program can secure either one device or up to ten devices and keep the whole network safe from malware such as worms, spyware, rootkits, etc. For getting Norton Setup, visit norton.com/setup , norton.com/setup .
    MS Office is used by a lot of people on a variety of devices like Android, Mac, PC, laptops, and iOS. This Office setup is specially programmed and adapted to do an array of tasks. Microsoft Office provides a list of helpful and dynamic features to accomplish the majority of tasks. To get this amazing setup for any devices, visit office.com/setup.
    McAfee antivirus offers end to end protection from malware, fastest security against viruses on the computer files and folders, useful and accurate anti-spam security, and secures your browsing data on the internet. Visit the website mcafee.com/activate to download, install and activate McAfee setup on your device.

    ReplyDelete
  8. All of your solutions in one place. Just ask experts, they can give you the best solution to your problems. Norton Antivirus protects your pc against virus, trojan and malware 24*7.
    Norton.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  9. http://www.onlinepszichologia.hu/blog/blogpost/69
    http://barahander.dinstudio.se/guest_4.html
    https://www.iangreen.net/guestbook/
    https://www.msh.org/blog/archive/201110
    http://presurfer.blogspot.com/2017/02/the-perfection-of-paper-clip.html
    http://candtkimball.blogspot.com/2017/03/ideas-2012-beautiful-home-interior.html
    https://dlazba-ploty.cz/index.php?option=com_phocaguestbook&id=1
    http://howapoemhappens.blogspot.com/2010/09/john-hodgen.html
    http://roscaizquierda.diariolibre.com/2011/10/31/se-como-se-terminar-con-los-problemas/
    http://carolabinder.blogspot.com/2014/03/consumption-contagion-and-income.html

    ReplyDelete
  10. home.mcafee.com - The menu bar of the McAfee home page gives you the options to manage your account. It includes For Consumer, Region
    Home.mcafee.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. I found this is an informative blog and also very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this blog norton.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  12. Roku is an official link that helps user to activate their roku device or TV. In order to activate roku tv or device, user should have roku activation code.

    roku.com/link

    ReplyDelete
  13. Roku is an official link that helps user to activate their roku device or TV. In order to activate roku tv or device, user should have roku activation code.

    roku.com/link

    ReplyDelete
  14. The hp support is actually a website which is set up by HP technicians to help people set up their HP Printer by downloading the printer drivers and other software through this website.
    hp.com/support ,
    www.hp.com/support

    ReplyDelete
  15. Go to mcafee.com/activate & enter the activation key to get protection. Download, install and activate McAfee at www.McAfee.com/Activate.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Trend Micro Software, a highly rated antivirus software that can be easily installed and run fast. Within a few seconds, it can defend yourself and your family. You can plan it manually or you can Scan automatically. Trend Micro will continue to defend you day and night. However check out the Prerequisite before download and install Trend Micro on your PC.
    www.trendmicro.com.au downloadme | www.trendmicro.com/downloadme |
    trendmicro.com/downloadme

    ReplyDelete
  17. http://sling-sling.com"> Sling.com/Activate Roku Steps, Sling TV Packages   Sling TV offers you an amazing alternative for cable at a cheap price. You can avail of many live channels including local channels with the Sling TV package subscription. Sling TV is supported on many devices including Roku.
    http://sling-sling.com"> http://sling-sling.com/

    ReplyDelete
  18. www.webroot.com/safe, Activate Your Webroot Safe setup at Webroot.com/safe as installing Webroot SecureAnywhere in Your PC. Download, install and activate webroot at www.webroot.com/activate. This may be a best place to introduce yourself and your website or include some credits.
    www.Webroot.com/Safe
    www.webroot.com/activate

    ReplyDelete
  19. Go to www.office.com/setup Sign in with your Microsoft account, or create one if you do not have one. Be certain to take into account this account so that you can install or reinstall Office later, without a product key.www.office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  20. Go to webroot safe website www.webroot.com/safe or webroot.com/safe from your browser.2.Sign in Webroot account with your Credentials.3.Enter your Webroot Keycode have 20 digits.4.Click on Next button to register your Webroot product.5.Accept the Agree and Install button to proceed.6.Finally your Webroot safe is activated successfully.
    This may be a best place to introduce yourself and your website or include some credits.
    www.webroot.com/safe
    webroot.com/safe
    webroot safe
    its very intresting to know by your very fruitful information and you are providing a very usefull information in all the fields too . Go to webroot safe website www.webroot.com/safe or webroot.com/safe from your browser.2.Sign in Webroot account with your Credentials.3.Enter your Webroot Keycode have 20 digits.4.Click on Next button to register your Webroot product.5.Accept the Agree and Install button to proceed.6.Finally your Webroot safe is activated successfully.
    This may be a best place to introduce yourself and your website or include some credits.
    www.webroot.com/safe
    webroot.com/safe
    webroot safe

    ReplyDelete
  21. Ik ben erg onder de indruk van het lezen van je blog. Blijf deze waardevolle blogs delen. telefoon telefoon bellen Instagram

    ReplyDelete
  22. Ik ben erg onder de indruk van het lezen van je blog. Blijf deze waardevolle blogs delen Instagram bellen

    ReplyDelete
  23. Frontier Airlines Reservations Much obliged for the pleasant blog. It was exceptionally valuable for me. I'm cheerful I discovered this blog. Much obliged to you for imparting to us, I also consistently discover some new information from your post.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Southwest Airlines Reservations Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I’m happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us, I too always learn something new from your post.

    ReplyDelete
  25. American Airlines Reservations Much obliged for the pleasant blog. It was exceptionally valuable for me. I'm cheerful I discovered this blog.

    ReplyDelete
  26. I found this kind of articles since long time. Your article is wonderful and the quality of your content is also very good. You are a good choice for the subject. I am impressed with your writing skills.

    Canon is commonly used in local and commercial areas of the printer. Also, it works on WI-FI technology so you can share photos from place to easily print your picture and fastest way. Visit us - http //ij.start.canon setup

    ReplyDelete
  27. Printers are friendly tools you can find everywhere these days, whether at office or at home. They are an essential part of office supplies, giving you the ease of printing your documents any time for more information on printer goto
    solutions brother.com/windows

    ReplyDelete
  28. Of the many metrics and pieces of data you'll want to track on Facebook, your cost per conversion may be one of the most important. Facebook ads cost money, but generally only charge you when the ad's goal is met. Therefore, your cost per conversion is directly related to your total ad spend.For more information Facebook Telefoonnummer

    ReplyDelete
  29. The ratio is positively associated with the Gini index of income inequality in a country ... Van den Bulte and Stremersch: Social Contagion and Income Heterogeneity in New Product Diffusion ... Bass diffusion model to consumer durables.
    --------------------------------
    Gmail Telefoonnummer

    ReplyDelete
  30. Thanks for this blog. It is really helpfull.for more information go here
    PayPal Nederland

    ReplyDelete
  31. Look for the complete guide at canon site and learn to get started to Canon inkjet setup. Find the best and easy methods and set up Canon printer hardware . ij.start canon , ij.start canon , ij.start.canon


    ReplyDelete
  32. 123.hp.com/laserjet | hp123.com/setup you can print high-quality documents and graphic outputs using the wireless connection. Canon printer is shipped with a setup CD to quickly access the software needed for your printer.
    ij.start canon | ij.start.canon | http // ij.start.canon |
    ij.start canon

    ReplyDelete
  33. Microsoft office.com/setup home & student 2019
    is an all-in-one software package that makes calculations, presentations as well as making reports easy. Microsoft, a United States-based company succeeds in delivering the massive software pack of software for the official pack.

    ReplyDelete
  34. For downloading, installing, and activating the Webroot antivirus software on a computer system, firstly, you need to navigate to the product website. You can navigate to the website through the link that is mentioned here: webroot.com/safe.

    ReplyDelete
  35. It is the Microsoft office setup home student 2019
    that is used for multipurpose work like Excel, Word, PowerPoint, etc. This new featured office provides you a new way to create your own presentation or business.

    ReplyDelete
  36. To Setup office home and student 2019, user should have Office product key that need to be activate with Microsoft Account online at URL Office.com/setup. To activate the product key, user should have a Microsoft account. Do remember the MS Office account details so that you can user is later for reinstallation of your office product.
    Office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  37. If your office.com/setup home and student 2019 subscription plan includes the desktop version of the Office apps you won't see an option to install it unless someone in your organization assigned a license to you.

    ReplyDelete
  38. If you are using any other Microsoft service such as OneDrive, Outlook, Skype, or Xbox Live, it means you already have an account that you can use for any Microsoft activity. Microsoft365.con/setup , Microsoft365.con/setup , office.con/setup

    ReplyDelete
  39. this is now become a global thing like income inequality thanks for telling us, canon printer by putting the for the ink in the canon printer and all a user seems to be works so better if they had some knowledge about the canon printer and used it in there to forward their printing.how it is associated to each of the other persons when it has to be fully in making the things good to perform in all of it, v

    ReplyDelete
  40. wonderful blog, it is informative and it was very informative. i must say you shared such quality key points with us.

    ReplyDelete
  41. this is really a helpful blog for every one The trends of rising income inequality and the declining national savings rate since the early 1980s may be related, according to a paper by Marianne Bertrand and Adair Morse.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Using your Microsoft Account associated with office to sign in will take you to the Dashboard for Office installation, If you are new to Office, you can create a New account and enter Product key to redeem and Install Office. office.com/setup
    www.office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  43. Canon Printers are one among the simplest printers within the industry. The highly versatile beat one printer has features that make them stand out among others.
    canon.con/ijsetup | 123.hp.com/setup | 123.hp.con/setup |
    norton.com/setup | norton.con/setup | norton.com/setup | norton.con/setup



    ReplyDelete
  44. FuboTv is one of the great value packed streaming service providers for which many people are going for it. You can access and watch FuboTv on your streaming device. there are two options to sign-in or login on FuboTV. Activate your FuboTV by clicking on fubo.tv/activate. You will get this option of fuboTv activate after you successfully login on to your device. If you remember your login credentials, log in with your email id and password and launch fuboTv connect on your streaming device.
    fubo.tv/Connect

    ReplyDelete
  45. Your post is very good, thankyou for putting up such a good post.
    You should check our website, you will get a lot of good information and if all your questions are solved, then you can download ij start canon our website.
    https://ijstartcanonx.com/

    ReplyDelete
  46. Here I am for the first time, and I found beneficial information. Very nice and well-explained article. Thanks for sharing!
    McAfee.com/Activate

    ReplyDelete
  47. Thanks for sharing this informative content it will help me to study this topic.


    Texas CRM software
    is a deployed type of business software that offers aid to different businesses to manage long-term client connections, store data more efficiently to increase business productivity. It also helps to distribute workload, maintain healthy relationships with already existing customers, catch new customers to increase ROI.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Open officesetup on home page, and click & Install Office& or Office 356 apps option to begin
    office.com/setup home & student 2019
    , www.trendmicro.com/activate , norton.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  49. Garmin Express download is a system that updates the devices of Garmin. It can also manage the Garmin devices too. You just need to download and install the software on your device and automatically it receives all the Garmin device information. You can even save the whole information Stored on the Garmin device.
    garmin.com/express
    garmin express

    ReplyDelete
  50. I like the important data you give on your articles. I will bookmark your blog and return to here routinely.
    Hi, Here I will reveal to you the best printer for every day use. Here we have GIFT Redemption Process to purchase canon.com/ijsetup.
    Stage 1: Verify Your Mobile Number.
    Stage 2: Enter the Product Serial Number.
    Stage 3: Your GIFT will be conveyed to your location inside 45 days after all confirmations.
    In the event that more question, Visit on our Website.
    Thanks.
    https://sites.google.com/view/ijstartcanonx

    ReplyDelete
  51. Download and install Canon ij setup from Cannon/ijsetup to start using powerful features packed into the incredibly compact bodies of your Canon printer. You can find multiple ranges of printers such as canon inkjet selphy, Maxify, Canon mg3620 ink, Canon mx490 ink, or others.
    cannon/ijsetup | Cox webmail Login | Skype Login

    ReplyDelete
  52. Microsoft is an official portal to activate and start your Microsoft 365 product including office apps, cloud services and other collaboration services. You’ll need to Sign In and enter Microsoft product key
    microsoft365.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  53. ij.start canon is an official support site or a portal that allows you to feasibly download Canon ij start printer setup from ij.start.canon and install successfully. http://ij.start.canon , https://ij.start.canon

    ReplyDelete
  54. Wow! Such an amazing blog. Thanks for sharing with us such a mind-blowing post.
    ij start canon printer is wildly popular due to its versatile and all-in-one features that enable you to print, copy and scan files effectively. With this printer you get so many new feature. If you want to buy this printer and know more information about this printer, Visit my site: https://ijstartcannonx.com/

    ReplyDelete
  55. Canon printer comes with numerous types, including multifunction, single function, photo print, scanning, copy, and other so many features; however, setting up a Canon model requires an almost similar process. ij.start.canon |
    ij.start canon |
    http://ij.start.canon | https://ij.start.canon

    ReplyDelete
  56. Get free Outlook email and calendar, plus Office Online apps like Word, Excel and PowerPoint. Sign in to access your Outlook, Hotmail or Live email account.
    hotmail.com login | www.amazon.com/mytv

    ReplyDelete
  57. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  58. 192.168.0.1 is the default gateway that is used by routers and modems such as D​-Link as default IP address for logging the admin panel.
    192.168.0.1 | 192.168.1.1

    ReplyDelete
  59. I Will Help you to Install the setup canon ij setup. It requires to switch on of your printer to proceed online activate. So if it is Wireless then you can set up by the online updates.
    The better quality printer supports high-speed printing and works on quality performance. https://ijstartcannonx.com/

    ReplyDelete
  60. xfinity.com/authorize - this is the official website that allows clients to access the Xfinity Gateway. Discover the best cable, music, and phone deals online. By interacting for the entertainment bundle with Xfinity authorize. Enter xfinity activation code of 6 digit at www.xfinity.com/authorize or xfinity.com/activate to enable the Xfinity Gateway.

    xfinity.com/authorize | www.xfinity.com/authorize

    ReplyDelete
  61. We provide the best printer service. Set Canon inkjet printer and make sure that you get great results. You will get many new features from this printer. We provide you all kinds of information about Canon printers. You can also get online printer repair service suggestions from this site. canon ij setup

    ReplyDelete
  62. Thanks for sharing the informative article. It is really valuable Information and helped me to get some nice ideas. Keep doing such great work.
    ij.start.canon offers the Printer Setup download interface where you can introduce the printer arrangement further. With the online arrangement, the client can set up the Canon Printer Model. At the point when you do associate the Canon printer into your pc, your framework doesn't have to introduce the driver on it. Canon printer that can be downloaded through page is the best remote printer that you can interface with your gadget and print information easily. Canon setup CD isn't the appropriate strategy to utilize arrangement establishment for more. canon ij setup establishment manage appears on this page further. One can likewise introduce from another inception if your gadget is having issues in the online establishment or some other. Visit our site on

    ReplyDelete
  63. Following are the troubleshooting actions that users can take to resolve the issue. Users can also request assistance from customer service to resolve this issue. Now that you know what actions to take, let's take a look at how to prevent Netflix from updating automatically.............. Netflix Bellen

    ReplyDelete
  64. You can login to the Suddenlink email account from your Android device by adjusting the correct Suddenlink email settings to it. Therefore, follow the instructions below:
    mcafee not responding
    kaspersky antivirus not installing
    cancel noggin subscription
    suddenlink.net email settings

    ReplyDelete
  65. Introducing the right wallets for this digital currency is relatively simple. Because https://www.gooyait.com/1400/08/18/%d9%87%d9%85%d9%87-%da%86%db%8c%d8%b2-%d8%af%d8%b1%d8%a8%d8%a7%d8%b1%d9%87-%d8%a7%d8%b1%d8%b2-%d8%af%db%8c%d8%ac%db%8c%d8%aa%d8%a7%d9%84-%da%a9%db%8c%d8%b4%d9%88-%d8%a7%db%8c%d9%86%d9%88.html all digital currencies based on the Atrium network are supported by some network-specific wallets. So from the beginning, there were wallets to support Kisho Ino.

    ReplyDelete
  66. Nice post
    here I want to say that,
    I am Elina Thomas, my company provides technical support to customers who have any issue with their laptop & computer(hardware and software), and printer, etc. Our technicians who have more knowledge about it will help you in resolving your issue properly within a minute, available 24*7.
    for any query support related to any software and hardware you can go to LinkedIn Bellen

    ReplyDelete
  67. One option is to simply ask your acquaintances for money. The second option is to transfer money from your savings account to your PayPal wallet.
    PayPal Bellen

    ReplyDelete
  68. Daftar Situs Agen Slot Online

    Fokus utama kami ialah keamanan dan kenyamanan setiap anggota maka dari itu setiap harinnya Wahana138 berusaha semaksimal mungkin untuk memberikan pelayanan maksimal sehingga timbul kepercayaan serta kepuasan bagi setiap pemain Wahana138.

    ReplyDelete
  69. Ever heard of a https://yodesiserial.pro/">dеsisеrials? This in-depth blog explores these gripping episodic narratives that span books, games, podcasts and more. Discover what makes dеsisеrials so binge-worthy.

    ReplyDelete
  70. Can't get enough of your favorite desi serials?Yo Desi Serial serves up the most popular Hindi serials online. This blog dives into the juicy plot twists that keep audiences coming back for more.

    ReplyDelete

Comments appreciated!