Wednesday, June 24, 2015

Forecasting in Unstable Environments

I recently returned from the International Symposium on Forecasting "Frontiers in Forecasting" conference in Riverside. I presented some of my work on inflation uncertainty in a session devoted to uncertainty and the real economy. A highlight was the talk by Barbara Rossi,  a featured presenter from Universitat Pompeu Fabra, on "Forecasting in Unstable Environments: What Works and What Doesn't." (This post will be a bit more technical than my usual.)

Rossi spoke about instabilities in reduced form models and gave an overview of the evidence on what works and what doesn't in guarding against these instabilities. The basic issue is that the predictive ability of different models and variables changes over time. For example, the term spread was a pretty good predictor of GDP growth until the 1990s, and the credit spread was not. But in the 90s the situation reversed, and the credit spread became a better predictor of GDP growth while the term spread got worse.

Rossi noted that break tests and time varying parameter models, two common ways to protect against instabilities in forecasting relationships, do involve tradeoffs. For example, it is common to test for a break in an empirical relationship, then estimate a model in which the coefficients before and after the break differ. Including a break point reduces the bias of your estimates, but also reduces the precision. The more break points you add, the shorter are the time samples you use to estimate the coefficients. This is similar to what happens if you start adding tons of control variables to a regression when your number of observations is small.

Rossi also discussed rolling window estimation. Choosing the optimal window size is a challenge, with a similar bias/precision trade-off. The standard practice of reporting results from only a single window size is problematic, because the window size may have been selected based on "data snooping" to obtain the most desirable results. In work with Atsushi Inoue, Rossi develops out of sample forecast tests that are robust to window size. Many of the basic tools and tests from macroeconomic forecasting-- Granger casualty tests, forecast comparison tests, and forecast optimally tests-- can be made more robust to instabilities. For details, see Raffaella Giacomini and Rossi's chapter in the Handbook of Research Methods and Applications on Empirical Macroeconomics and references therein.

A bit of practical advice from Rossi was to maintain large-dimensional datasets as a guard against instability. In unstable environments, variables that are not useful now may be useful later, and it is increasingly computationally feasible to store and work with big datasets.

64 comments:

  1. Do you happen to have a link to a paper that shows "But in the 90s the situation reversed, and the credit spread became a better predictor of GDP growth while the term spread got worse." Thanks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rossi cited Ng and Wright (2013), see Figure 2:
      http://www.columbia.edu/~sn2294/pub/ng-wright-jel.pdf

      Delete

  2. اگر قصد ادامه ی تحصیل و یا کار در سایر کشور ها نظیر استرالیا، کانادا و غیره را دارید قطعاً به یک وکیل مهاجرت
    نیاز خواهید داشت. برای دریافت مشاوره در رابطه با انواع مهاجرت و جدید ترین قوانین و شرایط حاکم با ما تماس بگیرید.
    وکیل مهاجرت
    http://iranau.com

    با عضویت در رایگان در سامانه ی کماچ می توانید
    سفارش آنلاین نان
    دهید و نان تازه را درب منزلتان تحویل بگیرید.
    سفارش آنلاین نان
    https://komuch.com
    تجهیزمد شرکتی فعال در حوزه ی
    تجهیزات پزشکی در شیراز
    تجهیزات پزشکی در شیراز
    است که علاوه بر عرضه ی انواع دستگاه های پزشکی زیبایی پوست و مو، برگزار کننده ی دوره های آموزشی کار با دستگاه های پزشکی نیز می باشد. برای اطلاع از جدید ترین دستگاه های ما و دریافت مشاوره ی رایگان خرید از سایت ما دیدن فرمایید
    http://tajhizmed.ir

    Lowest prices in best online store ‘s Weekly sales
    buy online everything you need!
    https://aixonne.com


    برای دریافت خدماتی از قبیل:
    طراحی فروشگاه اینترنتی در شیراز
    سئو، بهینه سازی موتور جست و جو، بهینه سازی سیستم فروش در فروشگاه اینترنتی، بازاریابی اینترنتی، تولید محتوا، دیجیتال مارکتینگ
    برندینگ، راه اندازی استارتاپ ها، ارائه دهنده ی صد ها مقاله ی آموزشی رایگان در حوزه ی تجارت الکترونیک
    با ما تماس بگیرید.
    طراحی سایت در شیراز
    https://shirazsun.net

    برای درج آگهی نیاز به سرمایه گذاری نیست. تنها کافیست به طور رایگان در سامانه ی
    درج آگهی رایگان اینترنتی
    درج آگهی رایگان اینترنتی
    کافه نیاز ثبت نام کنید و هر گونه آگهی از خدمات تا ارائه ی کالا و خرید و فروش املاک و خودرو را در این سامانه ثبت نمایید.
    https://kafeniaz.com


    freight forwarder
    freight forwarder and amazon FBA shipping from china to everywhere in the world
    https://topshipping.cn

    ReplyDelete
  3. Many students are undecided about the best affordable custom research papers and informative speech essay help company to deal with due to the high number of companies that offer similar services.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Are you looking to hire the best Custom Research Paper Services? It is tedious and overwhelming crafting Research Paper Assistance Services for learners, Custom Dissertation Writing Service can be basic complex with detailed instructions from the teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you very much for sharing such a useful article. Will definitely saved and revisit your site https://oneworldrental.com/laptop-rentals-usa

    ReplyDelete
  6. HP PCs have been known to experience the ill effects of disappointments including split pivots, broken external laptop shells, motherboard issues, visit Fix HP Laptop Shuts Down Issue that will not fire up. Some of them can be credited to end client carelessness yet most of them can be ascribed to poor.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thankyou for the extraordinary post. Please do find the below attachments.

    Ringer for PC

    ReplyDelete
  8. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog.

    forum submission sites
    forum submission
    Forum Submission List
    Forum Posting
    forum posting site list
    forum posting site list
    http://godsofseo.com/high-da-forum-submission-sites-list/


    Question and Answer Websites
    Question and Answer Sites
    Question and Answer Sites List
    Question Answer Sites
    Question and Answer Sites for SEO
    http://godsofseo.com/dofollow-question-and-answer-sites-list/




    web 2.0 sites
    web 2.0 sites list
    best web 2.0 sites for backlinks
    web 2.0 submission
    web 2.0 submission sites
    http://godsofseo.com/high-da-pa-web-2-0-sites-list/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Entertainment can be more fun with Hulu as here you get access to a world full of your favorite TV shows. Here will get the opportunity to enjoy the latest content that you can stream in any of your devices supporting the app. Get your free trial and access to your device in the


    Hulu Login

    Hulu Plus Login

    ReplyDelete

  10. Garmin Express is an extremely versatile software application available for both Windows and Mac devices. However, you are required to check the specified requirements and ensure your system conforms to it. This is extremely important for flawless setup and unmatched performance.


    Garmin.com/Express

    ReplyDelete

  11. The software gives you desktop notifications and step-by-step instructions so that you can update your devices with ease. Even if your application is not open or the device is not connected to your system, it will give you alerts on a regular basis. So for garmin.com/express setup, you need to follow all the full-proof steps given below.

    Garmin.com/express

    ReplyDelete



  12. Garmin.com/express is a computer application for easily setting up, registering and managing your Garmin device. The software gives you alerts whenever there are new updates available so that you can install them easily. You can also save multiple maps and preferred places with Garmin Express.







    Garmin.com/express

    ReplyDelete

  13. Among all this, Product Activation Key is the most important requirement for Webroot Download. This 20-digit reference code combines a unique set of alphanumeric characters that identifies your Subscription Terms. You can get this code only after purchasing the preferred version of this software. This implies that you must purchase a Subscription.






    Webroot Download

    ReplyDelete

  14. Your Microsoft Office retail card or the receipt you purchased comes with an alphanumeric product key. If the activation key does not come with your product package, you should contact your retailer or Microsoft support in the correct manner.Nevertheless,





    Office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete

  15. An extensively famous and adored web-based email service, AOL Mail is now a renowned name. The mail service has gained its major fan following because of the fastest interface and features that are user-friendly. You need to choose this platform because here, you get convenient access to your emails and also enjoy several features that are brilliant.





    AOL Mail

    ReplyDelete

  16. AOL Desktop Gold is an advanced and easy-to-use version of AOL software. It includes the features of AOL mail with the personalized chat window and the AOL app that can be installed on both Android or iOS versions.







    AOL Desktop Gold Download

    ReplyDelete


  17. Magellan Roadmate Update provides the best possible guidance for GPS navigation. The Magellan Roadmate delivers a best in class GPS navigation experience with spectacular features. Also, it is developed with features to reduce driving stress, save time and money.




    Magellan Roadmate Update

    ReplyDelete

  18. Norton is an antivirus or anti-malware software product that provides users security with a variety of different virus detection methods. It offers real-time protection against viruses, malware, spyware, and other cyber-threats.





    Norton Login

    ReplyDelete
  19. We offer the types of assistance of assignment help online to the students who need help from our writing experts. Our expert specialists give different sorts of advantages by which the students can get the best grades in their assignments. Our Assignment Helper have faith in finishing the assignment inside the given time just as before deadlines with the master's help. We never miss the deadlines that make us quick assignment supplier to give the assignment writing services. Our services of assignment help online spare the students' significant time which the students can put resources into another significant subject.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Check out the option of assignment help in New Zealand to buy the assistance of academic writing. Online Assignment Help connects you with professional writers so you can get requisite help for your submission.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks for this informative article, I hope you will get the most positive response especially for this post. . .

    check mybalancenow,
    check target visa gift card balance,

    ReplyDelete
  22. Our Assignment Help professionals are always there to help you in writing the premium quality assignment that will not only boost your score but also increase your ideas related to the subject.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I simply began in this and I'm becoming more acquainted with it better! Cheers, keep doing awesome!
    Online Shopping

    ReplyDelete
  24. Find the best discounted men, women and kids shirts, pants, jeans, jackets and trouser and other accessories according to your fashion needs at BrandzHub. It is the most popular online shopping store located in Lahore, Pakistan. Do online clothes shopping in Pakistan ​with BrandzHub and get the maximum discount prices

    ReplyDelete
  25. Managing properties, collecting rents, maintaining a budget, scheduling repairs, posting as well as updating vacancy listings from time to time can be tiring as well as time-consuming. Not to mention, that we sometimes forget to do things on time and that affects us later. This is why Quicken Rental Property Manager is designed to help property managers get through all their work smoothly. The property manager tool helps you manage all your daily chores without forgetting anything. You can also automate and streamline many tasks and save yourself a lot of time and effort. To know more about Quicken Rental Property Manager 2019, visit our Quicken Help portal now.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Get best discounted price clothes and other accessories for men, women and kids at Brandz Hub. It is the most popular online shopping store located in Lahore, Pakistan. Do online clothes shopping in Pakistan ​with BrandzHub and get the best deals at maximum discount prices.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Your blog is filled with unique good articles! I was impressed how well you express your thoughts.

    ESAF Small Finance Bank | ESAF Small Finance Bank Netbanking

    ReplyDelete
  28. To make your writing more successful, you should go investigate the idea of the PEEL section. It assists you with giving the correct arrangement to your writing and keep on the right track. Critically, PEEL Paragraph is useful when you are dealing with your article. In article writing, you need to introduce your contentions to accentuate a subject.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Take the services of Assignment Help even in Australia for making your assignment submission successful and effective. Students can enhance their performance as well as their grades with the help of online assignment writing services in Australia.
    Assignment Help Australia

    ReplyDelete
  30. Research methods may be illustrated as a technique and tool that student utilizes to perform research. There are different types of research methods; it can be qualitative or quantitative. Research methods are considered to be an extensive-term yet the method of data collection and analysis. It represents the core that people have to address for so many elements to do better research. So, if you are looking for the best research to understand different types of research methods, you can hire our professionals. Our experts have outstanding skills and abilities that will surely help you gain the utmost benefits.

    ReplyDelete
  31. ConVox Omni-Channel Solution-Deepija Telecom
    Omni--channel contact center centralizes multiple communication platforms
    ConVox Omnichannel Solution enables communication across all popular channels like Voice,
    Chat, Video, Social Media & Email from a single user interface.Omni-channel is Suitable for Incoming & Outgoing Process, IVR Enabled Contact Centers,
    Customer Service Agency, BPO,KPO, Debt Collection, Insurance Marketing, Customer Surveys and Loyalty Programs.
    omni-channel, omni-channel contact center,
    omni-channel communication platform, omni-channel solution, centralized solution
    omni-channel
    ivrs
    ip-pbx
    Call Center Software
    Call Center Solution
    Call Center Solutions

    ReplyDelete
  32. We GoAssignmentHelp is a team of experts professional academic writers who provide proofreading services the best Online Assignment Writing Services programming assignment help with Online academic writing help - word problem solver - my assignment help in australia for Now you can get professional writing help personal statement help with all your academic writing easily!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Choose assignment help Service in New Zealand to buy the assistance of academic writing. Online Assignment Help connects you with professional writers so you can get requisite help for your Assignment.

    ReplyDelete

Comments appreciated!