Tuesday, April 2, 2013

Uncertainty as a Tool

At the Fed, uncertainty is frequently blamed for dragging down the economy. "There’s no question that slow growth, high unemployment, and significant uncertainty are challenges for monetary policy," John Williams of the San Francisco Fed remarked earlier this year. He added:
There’s pretty strong evidence that the rise in uncertainty is a significant factor holding back the pace of recovery now...More generally, research shows that heightened uncertainty slows economic growth, raises unemployment, and reduces inflationary pressures. This pattern has held over the past three decades, but the effects have been particularly notable in recent years. For example, capital spending has downshifted noticeably since early last year...  The job market also shows the effects of uncertainty...
Williams and other Fed officials have pointed to several sources of uncertainty. The fiscal cliff is an often-cited example, as is the European debt crisis. These sources of uncertainty are basically exogenous to monetary policy, but the Fed itself can also add or reduce uncertainty through its policies and communications. A handful of economists--George Shultz, Michael Boskin, John Cogan, Allan Meltzer, and John Taylor-- wrote in a Wall Street Journal editorial that "The Fed is adding to the uncertainty of current policy. Quantitative easing as a policy tool is very hard to manage. Traders speculate whether and when the Fed will intervene next."

If uncertainty really does have significant effects on the economy, and the Fed really can significantly influence the level of uncertainty, then a logical implication is that uncertainty management is a powerful policy tool. And yet, at least in most countries (with a notable exception that I will get to), this implication does not seem to be taken seriously. For all that policymakers bemoan the effects of uncertainty, they seem reluctant to seriously address it, which makes me wonder if it is simply a convenient scapegoat. Narayana Kocherlakota, President of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, called for more accomodative monetary policy in a speech on April 2.
I think that there are several possible approaches available to the Committee. For example, the FOMC could reduce the public’s level of policy uncertainty by clarifying the nature of the economic conditions that would lead the Committee to reduce or stop its current asset purchases....However, [this] would require the FOMC to make relatively complex changes to the language of its current communications.
He ultimately rejected the notion of using uncertainty management as a policy tool, however, calling instead for a lower unemployment threshold.

The notable exception is Turkey, where the central bank deliberately increased uncertainty to address its policy goals. The iMFdirect blog describes the situation:
In mid 2010 the Turkish central bank decided to introduce a policy that increased uncertainty in interest rates hoping that would stop foreign investors who were pouring money into the country in search of a quick buck... The Turkish economy was overheating. Money poured into the country from foreign investors attracted by a strong economy and high yields. A lending boom resulted in excessive growth along with an appreciating exchange rate and widening current account deficit. While evidence of success, these kinds of capital inflows are a headache policymakers would rather avoid, as they expose a country to risks that affect the economy and financial system as a whole, while undermining the objective of controlling inflation... 
Although targeting inflation, in 2010 the Turkish central bank became increasingly vocal about dangers to financial stability. In the absence of a timely response from the banking supervisor, it started to employ less traditional tools with an explicit purpose of addressing both price and financial stability concerns. A cornerstone of the strategy was using policies that created uncertainty.
The uncertainty-generating strategy entailed widening the so-called interest rate corridor. The upper end of the corridor is the overnight lending rate, and the lower end is the overnight borrowing rate. The iMFdirect explains,
In October 2010, the central bank sharply lowered the overnight borrowing rate, at which banks deposit money at the central bank, while keeping the overnight lending rate, at which the central bank lends money to banks, unchanged. By varying the volume of liquidity provided to the markets through repo auctions, which are essentially short-term collateralized loans, it started to generate a lot of volatility in the overnight interbank rate within this widened interest rate corridor... 
Previously, the overnight interbank rates were kept close to the policy rate at which the central bank provides liquidity through quantity repo auctions, indicating the potential rate-of-return for a foreign investor. As the corridor widened, the volatility of the market rates increased. While on average the market rates continued to be close to the policy rate, now it was the “floor” of the corridor that signaled to investors a guaranteed rate-of-return. Lowering it, it was hoped, would deter speculative inflows.
The Turkish central bank also began to provide liquidity to the markets through different repo facilities. By varying the amounts of liquidity provided through these facilities, the central bank could change the cost of lending to banks on a daily basis which creates uncertainty for local banks. Turkish Central Bank Governor Erdem Basci "confounded economists" with his latest move a few days ago. Bloomberg reports that
Economists are split on whether Turkish monetary policy is looser or tighter...BNP Paribas SA, Goldman Sachs Group Inc., Oyak Securities and Ata Invest interpreted the move as loosening policy to focus on boosting growth, while BGC Securities said it was contractionary. Morgan Stanley described it as “neither here nor there” and Finansbank called it “confusing.”
The iMFdirect post writes that it is too early to judge the benefits and drawbacks of Turkey's approach. They point out, and I agree, that the banking supervisor could have employed macroprudential measures sooner to address some of the concerns about excessive growth and capital inflows without the need for the central bank to use uncertainty to address these concerns. Still, it is interesting to see uncertainty added to the toolbox.


  1. The use of monetary policy as a primary policy instrument increases uncertainty and decreases real investment in favour of speculative investment in financial assets, as Kaldor argued. The data agrees.


    "The reader can probably make out from that chart that prior to 1969 the average growth in the rate of investment (red line) was significantly higher than after 1969 when monetary policy (blue line) became an increasingly important tool to manage the economy. The average growth in the rate of investment between 1947 and 1968 was 1.31% per year while the average growth in the rate of investment between 1969 and 2012 was 0.9% – a decline of over 31%. If we take the monetary policy era as having started in 1979 rather than in 1969 – we mention this only because it is the typical periodisation, whereas if we look at the data it’s clear that monetary policy came into favour in 1969 – but if we take the year 1979 as our starting point we achieve broadly the same, if not an even more dramatic, result: between 1947 and 1979 the average growth in the rate of investment was 1.25% per year, while between 1979 and 2012 it was 0.78% – a decline of over 37%.

    Meanwhile, the capital markets have indeed turned into a giant speculative casino. Interest rate targeting is, of course, not wholly to blame for these shifts, but it absolutely is a key factor. And indeed, most economists and policymakers would claim that this era’s prosperity (or lack thereof), which they refer to as the “Great Moderation”, is a result of the new “scientific” interest rate targeting policies. In reality, by using monetary policy shocks to steer the economy central banks are driving out the good investment and encouraging speculative Ponzi rubbish in the financial markets."

  2. In the early 90s it was pretty common for central banks to let the markets in the dark for what was about to happen.

    A friend of mine remembers talking to a senior member of the German Bundesbank at that time, telling him that a rate hike by a central bank should in principle be (my quote) 'big enough to create uncertainty whether the next rate move will be up or down'.

    That kind of policy went out of fashion after the bond market's 'crash' in 1994, when the Fed unexpectedly started raising interest rates quite aggressively.

    Lukas Daalder

  3. Can't one argue that uncertainty has long been in the FED's toolbox? The FED has quite recently made a point of being more transparent on what they do and will do in the near future, and also why. This reduces uncertainty about monetary policy. But this also means that in the past, there was deliberate creation of uncertainty of monetary policy (relative to the present situation.) In other words, uncertainty was used as a tool.

    Apart from that, whenever anyone talks about "uncertainty" you should really substitute "fear". Somehow, uncertainty about positives is never a problem, it is always uncertainty about negatives. For instance, do you think the certainty of the sequester is better than the previous uncertainty about it? Kocherlakota's remark is a good illustration of this. Anyone who does not realize this, will draw the wrong conclusions.

  4. Hey thanks for this amazing post. Would love to read more of such blogs. You can also have a look at Book a Cruise for more information.

  5. Hey thanks for this amazing post.
    pakistan business visa requirements is an online electronic travel authorization. which allows citizens of the respective countries to travel to Pakistan without requiring a physical stamp on their passport.
    Here are some Turkey visa requirements which is supporting document, such as a visa or residence permit from the Schengen area, USA, UK or Ireland. To find out which nationalities please visit our application page and indicate your nationality.

  6. I am extremely impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout on your weblog.Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it’s rare to see a nice blog like this one today. The online process simplifies the procedures and permits the user getting the permit quickly by Ukrainian embassy with the valid documents.Ukraine, a country lying in the heart of Travel peoples with the attraction places..and get the required regular visa for Ukraine by getting the evisa with the valid documents.

  7. I am satisfied that you just shared this useful information with us. Thanks for sharing wonderful information with us. Vietnam e visa apply online is a reliable and you get evisa for Vietnam on arrival portal which provides foreign visa for tourists and Russia visa with Russian e visa service. We provide clients with the fastest, easiest and cheapest way to get a evisa for Russian.

  8. Do you need Finance? Are you looking for Finance? Are you looking for finance to enlarge your business? We help individuals and companies to obtain finance for business expanding and to setup a new business ranging any amount. Get finance at affordable interest rate of 3%, Do you need this finance for business and to clear your bills? Then send us an email now for more information contact us now via (financialserviceoffer876@gmail.com) whats-App +918929509036 Dr James Eric Finance Pvt Ltd Thanks

  9. Thanks for this :) Online Turkish visa for the application of citizens of Armenia issued by the Turkish government to enter and travel in Turkey. Apply for your Turkey visa for Armenia citizens online as it is a much more convenient way to obtain a visa.

  10. Hi there thanks for sharing such an awesome blog. Always love to read your awesome blogs. My Regards you keep writing such awesome blogs.

    If you want an easy hassle-free Dubai and emirates visa experience you could visit our website and get it in 2-3 working days sitting at your home :

    "Emirates Visa Service"

  11. You have written very well. However, the information is never complete. But you have tried your best to understand this. You are a good writer.
    Book Cruise Packages
    mumbai to goa cruise ticket price 2021

  12. happened that day when I did not get the answer to my question. If you like to travel, then you can book these packages - Cruise tourism in India has become very popular recently. Because of this, Crodelia Cruise has been started. Search for you Cordelie cruise package.
    Cordelia Cruise Booking
    Cruise Cruises

  13. You provide very good information. I have read many articles before this. But no one has written as many details as I have explained to you.
    Tulsi Plant in Hindi
    Online Typing Karke Paise Kaise Kamaye

  14. Thank you for this work.. After the applying for application and uploading documents for Azerbaijan visa, you have to make payment for Azerbaijan visa fee online with the payment card.

  15. Attractive component of the material. I just stumbled across your web site and accession capital to say that I really enjoyed your site. With just a few clicks, foreign nationals can check online Kenya evisa processing time from their home.

  16. What an outstanding post! “I'll be back” (to read more of your content). Thanks…. Indian tourist visa or eTV for India is an online travel authorization. Foriegn travelers whose sole purpose of visiting India is for leisure, sightseeing, religious work or casual travel to visit their friends or relatives can apply for Indian tourist visa through online India visa application system.


  17. Wow, that's what I was looking for, what stuff! Present here on this website, thanks to the admin of this website.. Turkish businessperson visa , You can apply Turkish visa online through the e Visa Turkey website.It takes 3-5 minutes to fill in the online application.

  18. I appreciate your efforts. Thanks for your valuable articles. Do you know about the Indian visa photo requirements. It is available on this website. And follow all the guides at time to apply for a visa form. It increase chance your visa approval

  19. Your post is very great. I read this post. It’s very helpful. I will definitely go ahead and take advantage of this. You absolutely have wonderful stories. Cheers for sharing with us your blog. For more about tanzania visa visit at Apply to Tanzania Visa

  20. I hope you are having a pleasant evening. Are you looking for evisa to India? You can learn more about e visa to India on our web page about India e visa. Read here.....

  21. Thanks a lot for providing us with this excellent article material. Thanks a lot. Keep doing what you're doing. Good afternoon traveler, I am so happy to share with you the online Myanmar visa is available. You can generate the tourist & business visa request from your comfort.


Comments appreciated!